ERISA Compliance: Common Pitfalls to Avoid

The Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) of 1974 sets stringent standards for pension plans in private industry. While ERISA aims to protect the interests of employee benefit plan participants and their beneficiaries, compliance can be a minefield for plan sponsors and administrators. This article explores common ERISA compliance pitfalls and offers guidance on how to avoid them.

Common Pitfalls

Navigating the complex landscape of ERISA compliance can be challenging for even the most diligent plan sponsors and administrators. Despite best intentions, many find themselves stumbling into compliance pitfalls that can have serious consequences for both the plan and its participants. These pitfalls range from misunderstanding fundamental fiduciary responsibilities to overlooking critical administrative details.

In this article, we’ll explore ten of the most common ERISA compliance pitfalls. Understanding these issues is the first step toward avoiding them and ensuring your retirement plan operates smoothly and in full compliance with the law. By recognizing these potential problem areas, plan sponsors and administrators can take proactive steps to strengthen their compliance efforts and better protect the interests of plan participants.

Let’s delve into these key areas of concern:

Failure to Understand Fiduciary Responsibilities

Many plan sponsors and administrators underestimate the scope and significance of their fiduciary duties under ERISA. This pitfall often stems from a lack of understanding about when one becomes a fiduciary and what that role entails.

Fiduciaries are required to act solely in the interest of plan participants and beneficiaries, with the exclusive purpose of providing benefits and defraying reasonable expenses of administering the plan. They must act with the care, skill, prudence, and diligence that a prudent person would use in similar circumstances. Failing to recognize these responsibilities can lead to decisions that aren’t in the best interest of participants, such as selecting investments based on factors other than their merits or allowing personal interests to influence plan decisions. This misunderstanding can result in severe consequences, including personal liability for fiduciaries.

Inadequate Plan Documentation and Record-Keeping

Proper documentation is the backbone of ERISA compliance, yet it’s an area where many plans falter. This pitfall encompasses a range of issues, from outdated plan documents that don’t reflect current regulations to inconsistencies between plan documents and actual operations. For instance, a plan might be operating under amended terms that were never formally adopted or documented.

Another common issue is the failure to maintain adequate records of important decisions, such as the reasoning behind investment choices or changes to plan features. Poor record-keeping can also lead to difficulties in providing required disclosures to participants or responding to Department of Labor (DOL) audits. In the event of a dispute or investigation, inadequate documentation can leave plan sponsors vulnerable to legal challenges and regulatory penalties.

Mismanagement of Plan Investments

Investment management is a critical area where many plans stumble, often due to a lack of expertise or oversight. This pitfall can manifest in several ways. Some plans fail to establish or follow a formal investment policy statement, which should guide all investment decisions. Others neglect to regularly monitor and evaluate plan investments, potentially leaving participants with underperforming or overly expensive options.

There’s also the risk of offering an investment lineup that’s not appropriately diversified or doesn’t meet the needs of the participant population. For instance, a plan might offer too many similar fund options, creating confusion, or might lack low-cost index funds. Fiduciaries who aren’t investment experts themselves may fail to seek qualified professional help, leading to poor investment choices that can significantly impact participants’ retirement savings.

Errors in Plan Administration

The day-to-day administration of a retirement plan involves complex processes where even small mistakes can lead to significant compliance issues. Common administrative errors include miscalculating employee contributions or employer matches, which can result in participants receiving incorrect account balances.

Another frequent mistake is the failure to timely deposit employee contributions into the plan, which the DOL views as a serious fiduciary breach. Errors in eligibility determination can lead to wrongful exclusion or inclusion of employees in the plan. Vesting calculation mistakes can result in participants receiving more or less than they’re entitled to upon distribution. These administrative errors not only create headaches for plan sponsors but can also trigger costly correction processes and potential penalties.

Inadequate Participant Education and Communication

Effective communication with plan participants is not just a best practice—it’s a legal requirement under ERISA. Many plans fall short in this area, failing to provide required notices and disclosures to participants in a timely and understandable manner. This can include Summary Plan Descriptions, Summary Annual Reports, or notices about significant plan changes. Beyond these required disclosures, many plans fail to offer comprehensive education about plan features and investment options. This lack of education can lead to low participation rates, inadequate savings, or poor investment choices by participants.

Additionally, when plan changes occur, inadequate communication can leave participants confused or unaware of important modifications to their benefits. Effective communication is crucial for helping participants make informed decisions about their retirement savings and for maintaining compliance with ERISA’s disclosure requirements.

Non-Compliance with Reporting and Disclosure Requirements

ERISA mandates various reporting and disclosure requirements, which can be overwhelming for plan sponsors. One of the most significant is the annual Form 5500 filing, which many plans file late or incompletely. Large plans (generally those with 100 or more participants) must also undergo an annual audit, a requirement that’s often overlooked or inadequately addressed.

Failure to provide Summary Plan Descriptions (SPDs) to participants within the required timeframe is another common issue. These documents must be comprehensive, up-to-date, and written in a manner calculated to be understood by the average plan participant. Neglecting these reporting and disclosure requirements can result in significant penalties and increased scrutiny from the DOL.

Improper Handling of Plan Fees

Fee management is a critical aspect of ERISA compliance that many plans struggle with. This pitfall includes failing to understand and disclose all plan fees, which can be complex and multifaceted. Many plans don’t regularly benchmark their fees against similar plans to ensure they’re reasonable.

There’s also the risk of allowing conflicts of interest in fee arrangements, such as revenue sharing agreements that aren’t properly disclosed or managed. ERISA requires that fees paid from plan assets be reasonable, and fiduciaries have an ongoing duty to monitor these fees. Improper fee management can lead to excessive costs for participants, reducing their overall retirement savings. It can also expose plan sponsors to litigation risk, as evidenced by the numerous class-action lawsuits in recent years focusing on excessive fees in 401(k) plans.

Mishandling of Plan Contributions

The timely remittance of employee contributions is a critical ERISA requirement that’s often mishandled. The DOL has strict rules about how quickly employee contributions must be deposited into the plan, and late deposits are considered a prohibited transaction. This can occur due to administrative oversight, cash flow issues, or simply a lack of understanding about the requirements.

Another aspect of this pitfall is the incorrect calculation of matching contributions, which can result from errors in payroll systems or misinterpretation of the plan’s matching formula. Some plans also fail to follow their own definition of compensation for contribution purposes, leading to under- or over-contributions. These issues can result in costly correction processes and potential penalties, as well as negatively impact participants’ retirement savings.

Errors in Benefit Distributions

Distributing benefits correctly is crucial for both compliance and participant satisfaction, yet it’s an area prone to errors. One common mistake is the incorrect calculation of vested benefits, particularly in plans with complex vesting schedules.

Another issue is failing to obtain spousal consent for certain distributions, which is required for married participants in many cases. Plans also frequently struggle with required minimum distribution (RMD) rules, either failing to begin distributions on time or calculating them incorrectly. These distribution errors can result in tax issues for participants and potential disqualification risks for the plan. They can also lead to participant disputes and potential litigation, especially if errors result in participants receiving less than they’re entitled to.

Inadequate Cybersecurity Measures

As retirement plans increasingly rely on digital systems for administration and participant access, cybersecurity has become a critical compliance concern. Many plans fail to implement adequate data protection measures, leaving sensitive participant information vulnerable to breaches. This can include lack of encryption, weak access controls, or outdated security protocols.

Another aspect of this pitfall is the absence of a comprehensive response plan for potential data breaches. Without a well-thought-out incident response plan, plans may struggle to effectively address and mitigate the impact of a cyber attack. Additionally, many plans neglect to educate participants on cybersecurity best practices, such as creating strong passwords and recognizing phishing attempts. The DOL has recently emphasized the importance of cybersecurity in retirement plans, and inadequate measures in this area can expose plans to significant financial and reputational risks.

Best Practices for ERISA Compliance

To address the common pitfalls and ensure robust ERISA compliance, plan sponsors and administrators should consider implementing the following best practices:

Fiduciary Education and Documentation

Establish a comprehensive fiduciary education program to ensure all plan fiduciaries understand their roles and responsibilities. This should include regular training sessions covering ERISA requirements, recent regulatory changes, and case law updates. Implement a system for documenting all fiduciary decisions, including the rationale behind them. This documentation should be detailed and contemporaneous, serving as evidence of prudent decision-making processes in case of future audits or litigation.

Robust Plan Documentation and Administration

Develop a systematic approach to plan documentation and administration. Regularly review and update plan documents to reflect regulatory changes and plan operations. Conduct annual audits to ensure plan operations align with documented procedures. Implement a robust system for tracking and delivering required disclosures to participants. Consider using technology solutions to streamline administrative processes and reduce the risk of errors.

Prudent Investment Management

Develop and adhere to a comprehensive investment policy statement (IPS) that outlines the plan’s investment objectives, selection criteria, and monitoring procedures. Conduct regular investment committee meetings to review plan performance, ensuring that investment options remain appropriate and aligned with the IPS. Consider engaging qualified investment advisors to provide expertise in portfolio management and help fulfill fiduciary responsibilities.

Effective Participant Communication and Education

Design a multi-faceted communication strategy that goes beyond minimum disclosure requirements. Offer regular educational sessions on retirement planning, covering topics such as asset allocation, risk tolerance, and the impact of fees on long-term savings. Utilize various communication channels (e.g., email, webinars, in-person meetings) to reach all participants effectively. Tailor communications to different demographic groups within your workforce to ensure relevance and engagement.

Compliance with Reporting and Disclosure Requirements

Create a comprehensive compliance calendar that tracks all reporting and disclosure deadlines. Assign specific responsibilities for each requirement to ensure accountability. Regularly review and update Summary Plan Descriptions (SPDs) and other required disclosures to reflect current plan provisions and regulations. Engage qualified auditors well in advance of filing deadlines for large plans requiring an annual audit.

Proactive Fee Management

Implement a regular fee benchmarking process to ensure plan fees remain reasonable. This should include a review of both direct and indirect compensation to all service providers. Provide clear and comprehensive fee disclosures to participants, helping them understand the impact of fees on their retirement savings. Regularly review service provider agreements to ensure fee arrangements are transparent, reasonable, and in the best interest of participants.

Streamlined Contribution Handling

Establish clear procedures for the timely remittance of employee contributions, including a system of internal controls to flag any delays. Regularly audit payroll processes to ensure accurate calculation of contributions, particularly when dealing with complex compensation structures or multiple employee classifications. Provide thorough training to payroll staff on the plan’s specific rules regarding compensation and contributions.

Accurate Benefit Distributions

Implement a robust system for tracking vesting and calculating benefits, particularly for plans with complex vesting schedules or multiple benefit formulas. Develop clear procedures for obtaining necessary consents and approvals for distributions, including spousal consent where required. Regularly review and update distribution processes to align with current regulations, particularly regarding required minimum distributions.

Comprehensive Cybersecurity Measures

Develop and maintain a comprehensive cybersecurity policy that addresses data protection, access controls, and incident response procedures. Conduct regular security audits and penetration testing to identify and address vulnerabilities. Provide ongoing cybersecurity training for staff handling plan data and education for participants on best practices for protecting their account information.

Diligent Service Provider Oversight

Establish a formal process for selecting and monitoring service providers, including regular performance reviews and fee assessments. Conduct thorough due diligence when selecting new providers, considering factors such as expertise, experience with similar plans, and cybersecurity measures. Maintain clear service agreements that outline responsibilities, performance expectations, and termination procedures.

By implementing these best practices, plan sponsors and administrators can significantly enhance their ERISA compliance efforts. These strategies not only help mitigate the risk of regulatory violations but also contribute to a more efficient and effective retirement plan that better serves the needs of participants. Remember, ERISA compliance is an ongoing process that requires constant vigilance and adaptation to changing regulations and plan circumstances.

Conclusion

Navigating ERISA compliance is a complex and ongoing challenge for plan sponsors and administrators. The pitfalls discussed in this article represent some of the most common areas where plans may stumble, but they are by no means exhaustive. To ensure compliance and protect the interests of plan participants, it’s crucial to stay informed about regulatory changes, maintain robust internal controls, and regularly review plan operations.

Implementing best practices such as comprehensive documentation, regular audits, effective communication strategies, and ongoing education for both plan fiduciaries and participants can go a long way in mitigating compliance risks. Additionally, leveraging technology solutions for plan administration, reporting, and analytics can help streamline compliance efforts and reduce the likelihood of errors.

Ultimately, ERISA compliance requires vigilance, expertise, and a commitment to continuous improvement. By understanding these common pitfalls and taking proactive steps to address them, plan sponsors and administrators can better navigate the complex landscape of retirement plan management, ensuring the security and satisfaction of their plan participants while avoiding costly compliance issues.

Disclaimer: This article on ERISA compliance is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, tax, investment, or financial advice. While we strive for accuracy, ERISA laws and compliance requirements may change. This content is not exhaustive and may not apply to all situations. Plan sponsors, administrators, fiduciaries, and readers should consult qualified ERISA attorneys and professionals for personalized guidance on ERISA compliance matters. PlanTrust, its authors, publishers, and distributors assume no liability for actions taken based on this information. The ERISA compliance practices and regulations described here are current as of the publication date; readers should verify and stay informed about relevant law changes and updates to ERISA requirements. The technology solutions and services mentioned, including those offered by PlanTrust, may be subject to separate terms and conditions not fully detailed in this article.

---

Ready to Transform Your ERISA Compliance Strategy?

Navigating ERISA compliance doesn’t have to be a minefield. At PlanTrust, we leverage cutting-edge technology to turn ERISA compliance from a daunting challenge into a strategic advantage for plan sponsors and administrators.

Our advanced ERISA compliance management solution, built on 15 years of comprehensive Form 5500 data, helps you:

• Identify and address common compliance pitfalls before they become issues
• Automate plan documentation and record-keeping processes
• Benchmark your plan’s fees and performance against industry peers
• Streamline participant communication and education efforts
• Stay ahead of regulatory changes and reporting requirements

Don’t let ERISA compliance overwhelm your team. Take the first step towards more efficient, effective plan management.

Contact PlanTrust today for a free consultation and demo of our innovative ERISA compliance solutions.

📞 Call us: (800) 918-7305
✉️ Email: success@plantrust.com
🌐 Visit: www.plantrust.com

Empower your ERISA compliance efforts with PlanTrust – Where Technology Meets Employee Benefit Expertise.